I have to mostly agree with all the posts above me.
I do have something to add to all of this:
* Over the time I started to feel that the server has become too serious:
As much as I appreciate the work AntiTeal did, I have never liked that idea in general, to have a rank/skill plugin that you can get cool stuff for. Worth mentioning that it promotes tryharding even more, which we don't really want.
The skins we currently have are also not that special, as I'd rather have something silly or cartoony alongside some normal skins for people to use. It also applies to content, that we can unlock in general (which we lack and that is another huge problem).
* The server settings are really restrictive at this point and are aimed towards serious gaming. I'd love to spice things up on classic maps like icecap with randomized zr settings (gravity, speed, jump etc.) to make things interesting from time to time.
Overall, the server started losing what keeps servers going and that is fun.